z3.ca

Two Watersheds — excess institutionalization is bad

Illich’s core critique of modernity is that modern tools, broadly defined, have great benefits, but they have been over applied. As a result, many areas touched by modernity pass through two watersheds:

  1. In the first watershed, a modern approach improves a domain significantly.
  2. In the second watershed, the same modern approach is over-applied, causing “negative returns”, “marginal disutility”, general dehumanization, loss of autonomy, etc.

This rhymes a bit with Aristotle's Doctrine of the Golden Mean.

Also see Iatrogenic, meaning causation of a disease, a harmful complication, or other ill effect by any medical activity.

#mentalmodel

Last edited on Dec 2025